See Comments down arrow

Moore Mann

13 May 2020 | OP ED Watch

If you thought the spat over Michael Moore’s Planet of the Humans couldn’t get worse, you don’t spend much time online. But this much worse? It seems Michael Mann has accused Moore of being a Russian stooge. See, Climategate was Kremlin disinformatsiya and…

The fact that Michael Moore has suddenly said something with which you sympathize should not lead to uncritical endorsement of the way he said it, or his habitual views of the world. But the fact that Michael Mann has suddenly said something extremely offensive might lead one to a critical evaluation of the habitual argumentative style of such people including his former allies. Surely Moore can be wrong without being evil. And so can others Dr. Mann disagrees with. Can’t they?

Likewise, surely humans can be on the wrong track without being deplorable. Yet one of the points in Moore’s film that is deeply disturbing is the insistence that there are way too many of us and a bunch have got to go. Ecosystems certainly are under stress, and Moore is not wrong that human domination of the planet is on a scale, and accompanied by changes in the land, that are unprecedented. (The classic image of the world from space at night, with the incredible patches of light, is quite unlike anything any other species has wrought or conceivably could, as are the rivers that once caught fire in North America and those choked with plastic in Asia today.) All true. But can we not find a constructive way forward?

Many people seem eager to say no. And thus if you did and do find Michael Moore’s and other radical environmentalists’ anti-human views surprising, we regret to say that such ideas are very widespread among Deep Ecologists and some shallow ones too. And while Extinction Rebellion may at least have the idea of personally going first, too many others don’t.

Arguments should be evaluated on their merits. But one of their merits, or weaknesses, is the extent to which they appear to have nastiness hard-wired in. American writer David Horowitz, a New Left Marxist from the 1950s into the 1970s, later wrote sorrowfully that “What motivates radicals is not compassion for the lost soul of mankind, but the hatred of human beings as they are.” And when two groups with that quality in common have a falling-out, it’s not surprising that it’s very ugly indeed.

2 comments on “Moore Mann”

  1. Well stated insight which must be said.
    Yikes. Fascism this way —> self hatred is at the root of much evil.

    Stay well, be safe.

  2. I encourage you all to watch the film The Demographic Winter. It is available on YouTube. While we have a marked trend of increasing longevity which makes it appear that we are increasing in population globally, at the same time we have a downward population trend happening due to the reduced fertility and child-bearing in the majority of countries in the world. Once the Boomers pass into the Beyond, there will be a dearth of people to take their places and keep the economy, jobs, property values, etc on track. Anti-human ecologists and man-made global warming enthusiasts are getting their dreams fulfilled - humanity is on a downward spiral towards depopulation and potentially extinction!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *